By Douglas Hoffer, Partner. Reviewed by Daniel P. Smith, Esq. Last updated: July 30, 2025
This guide is designed to be the go-to page for catastrophic injury victims in New York. It is regularly updated to adapt to any changes in the legal landscape.
-
- Your First 72 Hours: Your immediate priorities are seeking emergency medical care, documenting every detail, and contacting an experienced catastrophic injury attorney.
- Severe TBI, spinal cord, and amputation cases in NYC can result in settlements well into the eight-figure range. Our firm has secured results such as a $50 million settlement for a child with brain damage and $5.5 million for a construction worker with multiple orthopedic and internal injuries after a scaffold fall
- Deadlines: You have a limited time to file a claim, with significantly shorter periods for medical malpractice cases and strict notice requirements for claims against government entities
- What You Need: A strong case is built on medical records, a professional life care plan, testimony from economic experts, and accident reconstruction.
- NY Specific Issues: New York’s unique laws, like Labor Law § 240 for construction workers, and a serious injury threshold for accidents, mean that professional help matters.
- We’re Here to Help: Partnering with us early on helps us provide the best possible outcome for your catastrophic injury claim.
A fall from a scaffold on a Manhattan construction site. A multi-car pile-up on the BQE. A surgical error at a top hospital. These moments shatter lives.
When an injury is so severe that it leaves a person with permanent disability, disfigurement, or functional impairment, it is considered “catastrophic.”
In New York City, thousands of families face this reality each year. The path forward is fraught with medical challenges, financial strain, and emotional turmoil. New York’s legal system provides a robust framework for victims to secure the compensation necessary for a lifetime of care.
This guide is your first step toward understanding those rights and taking back control.
What Defines a “Catastrophic Injury” in New York?
Legal Snapshot: A catastrophic injury is a severe injury that results in permanent disability, disfigurement, or a significant loss of function, preventing the victim from performing their usual daily activities.
Under New York law, a catastrophic injury isn’t just about the type of wound; it’s about the consequences. The landmark case, Licari v. Elliott, established the core principle: an injury is catastrophic if it prevents you from performing “substantially all of the material acts which constitute [your] usual and customary daily activities.”
The law looks at how the injury has fundamentally derailed your life. Medically, these injuries include severe traumatic brain injuries (TBI), spinal cord injuries resulting in paralysis, loss of limbs, severe burns, and significant internal organ damage.
From our firm’s experience, the single most critical element in proving a catastrophic injury is the “life care plan.” This is a comprehensive report created by medical and economic experts that details all projected costs, including ongoing care.
It transforms your suffering into a concrete number that insurance companies and juries can understand and respect.
Why NYC’s Injury Landscape Is Unique
New York City’s high-density urban environment, dominated by vertical construction and heavy traffic, creates a unique risk profile. Construction accidents, particularly those involving falls and collisions with commercial trucks, account for many catastrophic injuries.
The sheer scale and nature of life in the five boroughs create specific dangers. According to the NYC Construction Safety Report, Manhattan had over 260 construction-related injuries in 2023. This is where New York’s protective laws become so vital.
Similarly, while the city’s Vision Zero initiative has made strides, the constant interaction between pedestrians, passenger cars, and massive commercial trucks fighting for limited space creates a hazardous situation.
Claims involving New York’s Labor Law § 240 (the “Scaffold Law”) often yield significant settlements. This is because the law imposes absolute liability on owners and contractors for gravity-related accidents. Once the victim is paid, owners and contractors are left to work out indemnification and contractual defenses amongst themselves.
How to Secure Maximum Compensation: A 6-Step Action Plan
Step 1: Prioritize Emergency Care & Document Everything
Your health is the absolute priority. Seek immediate medical attention and ensure the emergency room staff documents everything, including how the injury occurred, your initial symptoms, and any loss of consciousness.
- Pro Tip: Ask for copies of all intake forms, doctor’s notes, and imaging results (CT scans, MRIs). This objective medical evidence connects the accident directly to your injuries.
- Legal Tool: The federal EMTALA law ensures that you must be stabilized and treated by a hospital regardless of your ability to pay.
Step 2: Preserve Evidence Immediately
The scene of an accident changes quickly. You must act fast to preserve the evidence needed to prove your case.
- Pro Tip: From our experience, hiring a private investigator within 48 hours can be a game-changer. They can secure witness statements while memories are fresh, photograph the scene before it’s altered, and identify nearby security cameras you didn’t know existed.
- Legal Tool: Your attorney will immediately send “spoliation letters” to all potential defendants. This is a formal legal notice demanding they preserve all relevant evidence, including broken equipment, vehicle data recorders, employee records, and video footage.
Step 3: Handle Insurance Companies with Caution
Soon after the accident, you will be contacted by insurance adjusters. Their job is to minimize the value of your claim.
- Pro Tip: You are only required to provide basic information. Do not give a recorded statement, discuss fault, or speculate on your injuries. Politely state that your attorney will be in contact.
- Legal Tool: Under 11 N.Y.C.R.R.§ 65-1.1 and §65-3.3, you must file an Application for Motor Vehicle No-Fault Benefits within 30 days of a motor vehicle accident to secure up to $ 50,000 in immediate coverage for medical bills and lost wages.
Step 4: Assemble Your Expert Team
A catastrophic injury case is won with credible experts. Your legal team will coordinate with a network of specialists to build an undeniable case.
- Pro Tip: The credibility of your treating physicians matters. We connect our clients with leading, board-certified neurologists, orthopedic surgeons, and rehabilitation specialists whose testimony carries significant weight in court.
- Legal Tool: A Life Care Planner, certified by an organization like the International Association of Rehabilitation Professionals (IARP), is the cornerstone of your damages claim. They will create a detailed, evidence-based report projecting all future medical and quality-of-life costs.
Step 5: Calculate the Full Scope of Your Damages
Compensation goes far beyond current medical bills. A comprehensive calculation includes both economic and non-economic damages.
- Pro Tip: Keep a detailed diary. Document your pain levels, daily struggles, and any activity you can no longer do. This personal account helps prove the “pain and suffering” portion of your claim.
- Legal Tool: A Vocational Rehabilitation Expert will provide testimony on your lost earning capacity. They analyze your career trajectory and calculate the full value of the income you will lose over your lifetime.
Step 6: Prepare for Litigation, Aim for Settlement
The strongest negotiating position comes from being fully prepared to go to trial.
- Pro Tip: We often create “day-in-the-life videos” that show the real-world impact of the injuries on our client and their family. This is far more powerful than simply describing the challenges to an insurance adjuster or jury.
- Legal Tool: New York’s law on comparative negligence (CPLR Article 14-A) means you can recover damages even if you were partially at fault. Your award is simply reduced by your percentage of fault. Never assume you don’t have a case.
5 Common Mistakes That Can Jeopardize Your Case
- Delaying Legal Counsel: The first few days are critical for preserving evidence. Certain notice delays sneak up fast, so it’s best to take action as soon as possible.
- Accepting the First Offer: Initial offers are always low-ball figures that don’t account for a lifetime of need. If you accept the first offer, you may be stuck with out-of-pocket costs later on.
- Posting on Social Media: Investigators will use photos of you at a family BBQ or a friend’s wedding to argue your injuries aren’t severe. Stay offline.
- Missing Doctor’s Appointments: Inconsistent treatment history is a red flag that insurance companies will exploit to devalue your claim.
- Hiring a General Practice Lawyer: Catastrophic injury law is a highly specialized field. You need a firm with a proven track record and resources to push your case forward and recover maximum value.
Expert Insight: A Dansker & Aspromonte Case Study
Result: $ 5.5 Million Settlement for a construction worker after a four-story fall. The case hinged on proving liability under Labor Law § 240. Despite the defense arguing our client was careless, the law’s absolute liability standard ensured the property owner was held responsible for the unsafe work conditions.
We secured a settlement that covered his multiple surgeries, permanent disability, and lifetime of lost income.
Our Notable Case Results
- Medical Malpractice – $50 Million: A 4-year-old boy suffered permanent brain damage from an anesthesia overdose during routine eyelid surgery. The hospital settled during trial after overwhelming evidence of malpractice.
- Motor Vehicle Crash – $31 Million: A 35-year-old NYPD officer sustained traumatic brain injuries, vertigo, and chronic pain after being T-boned by a NYC Transit vehicle during emergency response.
- Wrongful Death – $21.5 Million: Our client died due to a delayed emergency surgery following a sanitation truck accident. The case combined negligence and medical malpractice claims.
- Pedestrian Accident – $10.3 Million: A 22-year-old woman developed permanent, progressive epilepsy after being struck by an unsecured truck door while crossing a Manhattan intersection.
- Traumatic Brain Injury – $7.8 Million: A pedestrian was hit by a police scooter in Battery Park, suffering multiple skull fractures and lifelong vertigo, memory loss, and cognitive decline.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
How much is my catastrophic injury case worth?
In NYC, settlements can range widely. The final value depends on the severity of your injury, your age, lost earning capacity, the clarity of liability, and the quality of your legal case preparation.
What if I were partially at fault for my accident?
You can still recover damages. New York’s comparative negligence rule reduces your award by your percentage of fault.
How long will my case take to resolve?
Many cases settle within 18–36 months. If a case goes to trial, it can take longer. We push for the fastest resolution possible while never compromising on the full value of your claim.
What is the difference between economic and non-economic damages?
Economic damages are tangible losses like medical bills, lost wages, and future care costs. Non-economic damages are for intangible suffering, such as pain, emotional distress, and loss of enjoyment of life. New York does not cap non-economic damages.
Should I accept the insurance company’s first offer?
No. The first offer is a tactic to settle your claim for a fraction of its true worth before the full, long-term costs of your injury are known. Always consult with an experienced attorney before accepting any offer.
How do I pay for a lawyer if I’m unable to work?
Our firm works on a contingency fee basis. This means you pay no upfront fees. We only get paid when we win your case, with our fee being a reasonable percentage of the recovery.
Take the First Step Toward Justice
The aftermath of a catastrophic injury is overwhelming. You don’t have to navigate it alone.
Our firm combines decades of experience with a client-focused approach to get you the resources you need to rebuild your life.
Ready to find out how we can help? Schedule a free, no-obligation consultation with our experienced NYC catastrophic injury lawyers today. Let us handle the legal battle so you can focus on your recovery.
Disclaimer: This is informational only, not legal advice. Consult an attorney for your case. Individual results vary.
