Who Is At Fault In Backing Up Car Accident

Who Is At Fault in a Car Accident When Backing Up?

Driving a vehicle in reverse can be challenging, especially for young or inexperienced drivers. As a result, the most common back-up crashes occur in busy parking lots and narrow driveways. Even with vehicles traveling at low speeds, serious injuries can occur.

New York law requires that drivers operate their vehicles with care and attention. Vehicles are not permitted to move backward unless it is safe to do so.

How to Determine Fault in a Collision When Backing Up

If you get into an accident while backing up a vehicle, it may not always be your fault. Determining liability in a traffic collision is tricky, which is why you should partner with an experienced attorney. Legal experts use four different factors to establish liability in a car accident caused by backing up. These are the steps involved:

Determine Which Vehicles Were Moving

The Insurance Information Institute’s (III) facts and statistics from 2018 show collisions with parked motor vehicles accounted for 407 collisions and 1.2% of total fatal crashes across the US.

Stopped vehicles are typically not liable for accidents unless they are parked illegally. If you back into an unmoving car or pedestrian, the backing driver will most often be held responsible. There are exceptions however, and an experienced accident lawyer should be consulted to protect your rights.

Establish Which Driver Had the Right of Way

In collisions where both cars were moving, a car accident attorney determines which driver had the right of way. If one driver violated regular traffic patterns and did not yield to the oncoming car, that driver will likely be held liable for the accident.  There can be more than one responsible party to an accident however.  Every case is unique.  

In New York, legal experts will analyze traffic lanes, traffic signs, and traffic laws to determine the right of way. For example, in a parking lot, the moving car always has the right of way. If you were adhering to all traffic rules and another vehicle backed into you, then you should generally not be held liable for the collision.

Unfortunately, the backing vehicle may dispute your version of the accident and require you to fight for your rights. Even seemingly simple cases may be disputed.  If you are unsure whether you have the right to bring a claim after suffering serious injuries, speak to an experienced and dedicated lawyer.

Analyze Vehicle Damage

A car accident attorney can inspect where vehicle damage occurs to establish fault in an auto accident. The type of vehicle damage may suggest if the driver with the right of way had plenty of time to stop and let the other vehicle finish backing out of a space. It could also suggest that the right of way driver was not paying attention or speeding at the time of the accident.  Experts in accident reconstruction can be utilized to prove negligence as well.

Get Statements from Witnesses

To determine who is at fault in a car accident when backing up, witness testimonies can help. First, a witness can recount what happened for an official police report. Then, car accident attorneys use their statements as evidence to prove liability and collect damages for accident victims.


For a free legal consultation, call (646) 692-0204


Examples of a Back-Up Crash in New York

Despite slower speeds, back-up collisions can lead to severe damage to pedestrians or other vehicle passengers. An experienced and qualified car accident attorney can work with you to recover maximum compensation.

Legal experts know how to identify liable parties and negotiate fair settlements for accident victims. There are three main types of vehicle crashes that can occur when a car is backing up: 

Leaving a Parking Space

Parking lots are a hotspot for vehicle collisions. CBS News reports that one in five car accidents occur in parking lots. In addition, two-thirds of all drivers admit to being distracted by the radio, other people, and cell phones when pulling in and out of parking areas.

When reversing from a parking spot, drivers have a duty of care to look for pedestrians and other vehicles before departing. If the driver fails to do this and backs into another car or pedestrian, they will likely be held liable for the collision.

Multiple Vehicles Backing up at the Same Time

In busy parking lots, two drivers may reverse at the same time and collide. This could occur because the drivers were not paying attention, but also when one vehicle is in another driver’s blind spot. 

When two moving vehicles back into one another, both drivers may be at fault for the collision. If both drivers failed to make sure the area was clear before backing up their vehicles, both may be held responsible in some proportion. 

If you and another driver are partially responsible for the parking lot accident that resulted in serious injuries, establishing the extent to which vehicle is to blame is critical. You need a lawyer that can show that the other vehicle is mostly to blame.

Backing Out into Oncoming Traffic

Backing out of driveways and alleys can lead to a collision. The vehicle reversing has a duty to check for oncoming traffic when exiting the driveway and entering a new lane of traffic. If a car backs into oncoming traffic, that driver is typically liable for the traffic collision. 

Oncoming vehicles may share part of the responsibility in this type of accident depending upon the unique facts and circumstances 

For example, a car navigating down a roadway has the right of way, but they also have an obligation to pay attention and drive the speed limit. If the other driver could have avoided the accident, they share partial liability.

A New York Car Accident Attorney Can Fight For Compensation in a Back-Up Collision

If you have been seriously injured in a back-up collision, you may be entitled to recover substantial compensation for your injuries. An experienced car accident law firm will analyze your claim, gather and secure evidence to prove fault, and negotiate with the at fault party or parties. 

Every case is unique, and the facts are not always what they seem. Without a legal team on your side, you might miss out on financial recovery for damages caused by another driver’s negligence or accept less than you deserve. 


Click to contact our personal injury lawyers today


Call Dansker & Aspromonte Associates For a Free Consultation

Even if you are not sure if you have a strong claim, call the lawyers at Dansker & Aspromonte Associates at (646) 692-0204 for a free consultation. Our firm has been fighting for the rights of injury victims since 1988.

If you have been involved in an accident, don’t delay speaking to a lawyer as there are deadlines that limit the time you have to bring a claim. If you fail to file your claim by the deadline, you may be forever prevented from recovering the compensation you deserve.


Call or text (646) 692-0204 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form


  • Innovative Legal Strategies
    Each client that comes to our team gets a managing partner and trial partner dedicated to their case. We put our collective 75 years of experience behind your case to obtain the best possible outcome on your behalf.
  • Small Firm Dedication & Focus
    Our firm is different from most firms in our area in that we are a “boutique” type firm that is small enough to give personal attention to our clients and yet experienced and powerful with a reputation as a hard-hitting litigation firm.
  • Providing Answers & Solutions
    Our team is committed to always being able to provide you with updates on your case and answers to your questions. This is your case and we want to be sure you are confident every step of the way.
  • Proven Record of Success
    Dansker & Aspromonte has been advocating for the rights of the injured since 1986. We have the tools, resources, knowledge, and commitment to get you the best possible outcome.

Let Our Team Handle Your Case With Confidence

Contact Our Team Today
  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.